West Point Grey United Church
WPGUC
Nov 16, 2026

Fear, Risk, and Truth

Matthew 25:14-30

Let me begin with a question. How would you double your money?

Someone I know bought a forty-year-old house in Vancouver in 2007 for about $700,000. In 2017 she sold it for more than $2.2 million. Hearing that story, some of us feel a little envy. Some of us feel anger, because we or our children have been priced out of this city. Some of us feel gratitude, because a home that we or our families worked hard to buy still shelters us, and we know that today’s young families cannot easily do the same, no matter how hard they work. Many of us feel more than one of these at once. Let us hold that story for a moment, because land, money, and who ends up with them are central to today’s parable.

A wealthy man leaves on a long journey and entrusts his property to three servants: five talents to one, two to another, and one to the third. A talent was worth roughly fifteen to twenty years of a labourer’s wages. John Dominic Crossan reckons that the first servant had just been handed about two million dollars. Jesus begins with a fairy-tale sum.

The first two servants double what they were given, and they hear, “Well done, good and trustworthy servant. Enter into the joy of your master.” The third servant digs a hole and buries the money. He says, “I knew you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter seed, so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground.” The master calls him wicked and lazy and gives him a harsh punishment.

Let us listen again to three words from this servant: “I was afraid.” Everything we say today begins with them.

For most of Christian history, people have read the master as God, and the parable as a call to take risks. Burying money was a lawful way to keep it safe, so his failure was not wrongdoing but playing it safe. Scholars warn that this is the most abused parable in the New Testament, because some use it, especially verse 29, to bless investment and the prosperity gospel. It does not say that God wants us rich. It asks what we do with what has been entrusted to us.

But some scholars invite us to listen with peasant ears. In Jesus’ time, the top 2 percent held most of the wealth. The elite lent money to farmers at very high rates, and what they often wanted was the land. When a harvest failed, the loan was called, the family lost its land, and the land became vineyards and luxury for the wealthy. Let us hear the parable again in that world. The first two servants double a fortune very quickly. How could they do it? Perhaps through that same system of loans and land. The third servant refuses to take part and says aloud what everyone knows: this master reaps where he did not sow. He is a truth teller, a conscientious objector, and the master does not deny the charge. The master only attacks the one who spoke it. The one who tells the truth is punished for telling it.

There is more than one faithful way to hear this parable, and I do not ask you to settle it. Matthew places this parable among stories about the return of the Son of Man, and many hear the master as Christ. Others hear Jesus warning us about the empire’s economy, where the truth teller is harshly punished, which sounds like what happens to Jesus within days. Let us allow both readings to question us, because they meet at the same place.

Both readings meet in the third servant’s fear. Fear is what he names, and fear is what we know. We are afraid of losing what we have, afraid of the cost of speaking up, afraid that the church will not survive and that our small gifts are not enough. Fear is what buries things. Like a stone laid over a wellspring, fear stops the water from flowing. Fear keeps us quiet when we see neighbours squeezed by rents and debt in a city that seems to have no room for them.

Yet the parable shows two ways that fear can go. Fear can bury our gifts and keep us safe and silent. Or fear can be named honestly, as the servant names it, and become courage: “I am afraid, and I will not take part.” There is something faithful in that, even at the cost of everything. The greatest risk to our faith is not failure. It is a cautious, buried faith, not too cold and not too hot.

In this Season of Commitment, as we dream of being a church like a healing stream, let us ask what we have been entrusted with, our time, our gifts, our voices, and our faith in Christ, and let us not bury them in fear but let them flow out to bring healing to a hurting world.

A church like that learns together what our neighbours need and how to serve them. On the road to becoming an intercultural church, this congregation has kept some things and let go of others. You opened your doors and your hearts to invite neighbours from many places, and you have walked with them as companions, not as hosts who stay at the center. In my two years with you, I have been privileged to see that, and I am not alone: guests from the World Council of Churches have praised our unique worship and radical hospitality. I also want to praise something harder. You have worked, patiently and painfully, to overcome the colonial ways of seeing and the closed attitudes toward newcomers that many of us carry without knowing it. Letting go of these is slow work, and you have not given up. As we have been hearing in the series Becoming an Intercultural Church with Rev. Dr. Hyuk Cho, a church is called to exist less for the center and more for those on the margins, and let us hope to keep becoming that church together. Of the churches I know in Canada, none is more distinctive in intercultural ministry than West Point Grey United. May that make us not proud but brave, because a church that stands with the margins will be tempted, like the servant, to be afraid, and truth telling is what keeps the water flowing.

The joy of the master, if we dare to hear it, is not a bigger balance in the church account or a longer membership list. It is the joy of a community that sets down its fear and uses its gifts for love and justice.

Next Sunday, Reign of Christ Sunday, ends our church year, and with Advent we begin Year B and the Gospel of Mark. In this time of ending and beginning, let us ask ourselves some honest questions. What have we been entrusted with? Where have we buried it? What are we afraid of? And whose way are we following?

May we be a people who face our fear, tell the truth, and let what we have been given flow out like a healing stream. We do not need to see the whole road ahead. Even with our fear, let us take one more step together, trusting that we do not travel alone, in the care of a God who entrusts us with the world.